A Project I Stayed Away From

I first heard about Pi Network several years ago. The referral-driven structure looked like multi-level marketing to me, so I never paid much attention. That changed when my friend Théo contacted me about his accumulated tokens. Théo is a French entrepreneur who splits his time between New Zealand and Thailand and has moved his focus into crypto investing. He came to me with both excitement and questions, and that gave me a reason to finally dig into the project.

A Mobile Mining Pioneer With a Referral Engine

Théo told me he first heard about Pi a few months after launch. A friend showed him the app. What caught his attention was that it required no KYC and there appeared to be informal marketplaces where people exchanged Pi for real objects. Mining meant pressing one button a day, and the referral system allowed users to build teams. Even when Théo stopped actively mining after the first month, his team kept mining, and he continued to receive tokens. That is how he ended up with about 1,295 Pi.

Pi was truly early with this mobile mining model. Today we have tap-to-earn games everywhere, but six years ago this was different. It lowered the barrier enough for older and less technical users; Théo's father also started mining. That ease helped build a large community. The problem is that ease also made fake and duplicate accounts extremely simple to create.

A Relentless KYC Marketing Machine

When I looked at Pi's communication ahead of the TGE, almost everything was about KYC. The team pushed deadlines, created urgency, then extended the grace period again and again. The messaging was not about what the network does, what problems it solves, or how the mainnet will work. It was about collecting passports and identity documents. Théo saw the same pattern on their official Twitter account, where for the past two years nearly all posts seemed to be about KYC. It reminded me of identity collection models built around data rather than utility, and it raised a major red flag.

I generally avoid giving identity documents to centralized exchanges. I would rather trade on Hyperliquid than on platforms that require heavy KYC. So the pressure made me uncomfortable. Théo declined KYC for the same reason; he told me his ID is more valuable than a few hundred dollars of speculative tokens.

The 60 Million User Mirage

The network reportedly claims around 60 million users. I find that very hard to believe. Projects like Hamster Kombat show huge social engagement when they claim massive user numbers; Pi's engagement does not correlate the same way. Researchers have looked at on-chain data and found signs that the numbers do not add up. People can create multiple accounts with different phone numbers or free Facebook profiles, meaning one person can be counted several times. A person with two phones is counted twice. Even so, there do appear to be millions of real users. Some of them lost wallets, and many accounts look abandoned, but a genuine community clearly exists.

Market Cap Logic and the TGE Dump

If Pi opened at 40 or 75 USD, the market cap would be enormous. It would likely sit near or above Ethereum's valuation, which makes no sense unless large numbers of people choose Pi over Ethereum or Solana for actual use. I do not see that happening. Most holders joined because mining was easy and free, not because they needed the network. When tokens unlock at a TGE, many people sell immediately. We saw that pattern in recent airdrops: everyone rushes to the exit, and shorting the event can be profitable. That is the dynamic I expect around Pi.

Théo himself admitted he joined for easy coins, not utility. That is common. People short these events on Hyperliquid because sellers dominate the first wave. If the team later uses its advertising revenue to build something useful, the story could change, but that does not justify a high TGE price.

Price Scenarios: 0.20 USD or a Meme Coin Rally

My base case for launch day is around 0.2 to 0.3 USD per Pi. Community chatter has floated levels like 314 USD, but that is completely detached from market cap reality. I put the chance of something like 50 USD at only 5 to 10 percent. There is a scenario where Pi behaves like a meme coin and rallies because of its community, especially in Asia. Some Asian users seem more willing to treat Pi as a usable marketplace currency, while Western users look more likely to sell.

Exchange listings may not validate the project either. One major exchange CEO reportedly refused to list it and called it a scam, while others may list simply to collect trading fees. If enough retail buyers show up, the meme coin dynamic could carry it further than fundamentals suggest, but I would not bet on that.

A Pressured Launch or Another Delay?

I still would not call Pi a pure scam, and it is possible that the token lists and has some value. But I do not think Théo is sitting on 50,000 USD. My base case remains around 0.2 to 0.3 USD, with heavy sell pressure. There is also a plausible risk that the 20 February date turns into another grace period extension if the KYC numbers disappoint.

I will be watching whether the team actually launches, lists, and survives the first wave of selling. For now, the asymmetry between identity data collection and genuine utility keeps me cautious. The community is real, but the market cap math does not support the dream prices being thrown around.