What Counts as an Altcoin and Why Confidence Is Low

Altcoins are every cryptocurrency other than Bitcoin. Even though Bitcoin, Ethereum, and the US stock market have performed well in 2024, confidence in the broader altcoin category remains weak. Since early June, the total market value of altcoins has fallen from 1.19 trillion dollars to 967 billion dollars, a decline of more than 17%. That kind of drawdown is large enough to reset expectations across the market.

A few days before this analysis, Arthur Cheong, founder and CEO of DeFiance Capital, reportedly said the crypto market is probably maturing. His reasoning, as reported, is that extreme fluctuations of 70% or 80% every two years may be a thing of the past. Growth could become slower and more stable, comparable to the S&P 500 after the 2008 financial crisis. Under that scenario, some altcoins may still deliver big returns, but most would no longer be attractive long-term holdings.

Reading the Market Structure: Bitcoin and Ethereum Pull Away

To see why altcoin sentiment is weak, I look at the global crypto market over the past few years. In the standard breakdown, the yellow area represents total cryptocurrency market cap, the blue area represents total altcoin market cap, and the green area represents altcoin market cap excluding Ethereum. Last year, total crypto market cap increased significantly, but it remained well below the frenzy of 2021 and 2022. Bitcoin did not set an all-time high in 2023; its previous record was in November 2021 around $69,000, and the new record only came in March 2024.

The main reason altcoins have lagged Bitcoin is that they did not keep pace with Bitcoin's growth. Even though Ethereum often gets criticized for lackluster price action and recent on-chain activity, it still holds a solid position among altcoins. Compared with the two giants, the top 250 altcoins are disappointing. Many tokens that looked promising struggle to deliver high returns, and that creates a gloomy market mood.

At the same time, some emerging sectors with new developments, such as AI and Layer 2, have performed very well. This data points to one conclusion: the era of broad crypto gains is mostly behind us. Gains are now concentrated in a handful of sectors, and within those sectors, spotting the right trend and narrative becomes the critical skill.

Three Categories That Show Where Altcoin Energy Is Flowing

To make sense of the altcoin situation, I break the market into three main narratives: memecoins, DeFi, and Layer 1s.

  • Memecoins: Last year they generated more overnight wealth stories than lottery tickets and attracted a large amount of investment. This year they continued to perform, but the breadth of gains was smaller than many expected. Dogecoin and Shiba Inu still account for close to half of the memecoin market, yet they have moved very little. Most memecoin activity has shifted to Solana and, more recently, to Base. The best performing new memecoins have come from Solana, with tokens like WIF and Brett delivering five-figure returns to a lot of people.
  • DeFi: It is a fundamental layer of crypto finance and a likely foundation for the future, but recent performance has been mediocre. A recurring problem is that DeFi protocol tokens lack real use cases outside of liquidity mining. That limits their long-term value.
  • Layer 1s: Many Layer 1 tokens have generated multiple waves of growth. In general, Layer 1s are doing better than memecoins and DeFi. They represent the industry's core infrastructure, with Bitcoin and Ethereum far ahead. Their technology is mature enough to attract a large user base that constantly interacts with applications. Solana has been a standout, powered by a strong memecoin narrative, a unique ecosystem, and its position as one of the most used blockchains in this market environment.

What Lies Ahead: Polarization and the Few Winners

A question I get often is whether Layer 1s and altcoins still have a future. My view is straightforward: as long as the crypto industry exists, speculation will continue, and altcoins will still have a role to play. However, the polarization of the altcoin market will become more and more pronounced. There are simply too many altcoins now, and the largest share of assets is concentrated in leading projects like Bitcoin and Ethereum. That reality will keep overall altcoin performance mediocre, with only a few strong projects able to rise above the average.

This polarization is already visible. The total altcoin market cap includes hundreds or even thousands of tokens, but the meaningful price action and liquidity cluster in a small number of narratives and projects. The days when nearly every altcoin could rally with Bitcoin are largely over.

How I Filter Altcoins: Solid Technology or Solid Capital

For long-term holders, my advice is to be highly selective. If you do not want to spend a lot of time on deep research, there are two blunt criteria I rely on. The first is to choose projects with solid technology. Layer 1 chains are a good example because their technology is mature and stable enough to support real usage. The second is to choose projects with solid capital. When a strong market maker is behind a project, that project is less likely to suffer from a shortage of funding. It usually means there will be money for marketing, development, and ongoing support, which provides an additional layer of safety.

In my view, the future belongs to genuinely powerful projects. That power can come from technology or from financial strength. Both types can survive and thrive in a polarized market, while weak projects will continue to fade.

Conclusion: Altcoin Selection Has Become a Game of Power

The broad altcoin recovery many investors hoped for remains absent. The data points to a market where a small number of strong projects, backed by either mature technology or deep capital, capture most of the attention and returns. Memecoins still produce spectacular individual winners, but the category as a whole is uneven. DeFi remains a core part of crypto finance, yet its tokens need more real use cases to attract long-term demand. Layer 1s look structurally strongest because they combine infrastructure value with active users.

For anyone holding altcoins over the long term, the lesson is simple: pick powerful projects and be very selective. You do not need to chase every narrative. If a project can demonstrate either a solid technical foundation or serious capital backing, it has a much better chance of standing out as the market polarizes further.